Reviewer Guidelines

How to become a reviewer

Participation in the peer-review process is absolutely essential to the success and reputation of the journal.  Our endeavors to administer a fair and timely review process for all of our manuscripts and to publish only papers of the highest quality are largely dependent upon the efforts of reviewers like you. Your help with meeting these important objectives is greatly appreciated.

Most people are invited by the Editor of a journal to conduct a review. An Editor may approach you because you are a specialist in a certain field or research topic. Still, to be a good reviewer requires a certain skill set. If you think you would be a good reviewer for a specific journal you can always contact the Journal's Editors. 

Locate the journal you need to review for

You are notified by e-mail when an Editor or Editorial Office invites you to review a submission for a journal. Once you have agreed to review, an email with further instructions will be sent to you. These emails contain the journal title as well as an abstract of that manuscript. The same time login user name and password also provided for accessing the account. The reviewers also use this user and password for all review process and need not be registered again.  

Reviewer Recognition

United Life publication (ULP) would like to express gratitude reviewers for their contribution, without which it would be impossible to maintain the high standards of peer-reviewed journals. Reviewers’ names will be listed in the journal’s reviewer acknowledgement page.

Check that you have enough time

Reviewing an article can be quite time consuming. The time taken to review can vary greatly between disciplines and of course on article type, but on average, an article will take about 10 days to review properly. Will you have sufficient time before the deadline stipulated in the invitation to conduct a thorough review?

Understand what it means to accept to review and manage deadlines

Deadlines for reviews vary for every journal. The editors will provide information on deadline expectations with the review request.  If you feel the review will take you longer to complete than normal, please contact the editor to discuss the matter. The editor may ask you to recommend an alternate reviewer, or may be willing to wait a little longer (e.g., if the paper is highly specialized and reviewers are difficult to find). As a general guideline, if you know you will not be able to complete a review within the time frame requested, you should decline to review the paper.

Peer-reviewer responsibilities toward authors

  • Providing written, unbiased feedback in a timely manner on the scholarly merits and the scientific value of the work, together with the documented basis for the reviewer’s opinion
  • Indicating whether the writing is clear, concise, and relevant and rating the work’s composition, scientific accuracy, originality, and interest to the journal’s readers
  • Avoiding personal comments or criticism
  • Maintaining the confidentiality of the review process: not sharing, discussing with third parties, or disclosing information from the reviewed paper

Peer-reviewer responsibilities toward editors

  • Notifying the editor immediately if unable to review in a timely manner and providing the names of potential other reviewers
  • Complying with the editor’s written instructions on the journal’s expectations for the scope, content, and quality of the review
  • Providing a thoughtful, fair, constructive, and informative critique of the submitted work, which may include supplementary material provided to the journal by the author
  • Determining scientific merit, originality, and scope of the work; indicating ways to improve it; and recommending acceptance or rejection using whatever rating scale the editor deems most useful
  • Noting any ethical concerns, such as any violation of accepted norms of ethical treatment of animal or human subjects or substantial similarity between the reviewed manuscript and any published paper or any manuscript concurrently submitted to another journal which may be known to the reviewer
  • Refraining from direct author contact

Peer-reviewer responsibilities toward readers

  • Ensuring that the methods are adequately detailed to allow the reader to judge the scientific merit of the study design and be able to replicate the study, if desired
  • Ensuring that the article cites all relevant work by other scientists

Explain your opinion

Providing insight into any deficiencies is important. You should explain and support your judgment so that both editors and authors are able to fully understand the reasoning behind your comments. You should indicate whether your comments are your own opinion or are reflected by the data.

Classify your recommendation

When you make a recommendation regarding an article, it is worth considering the categories the editor most likely uses for classifying the article:

-Reject (explain reason in report)
-Accept without revision
-Revise ( Major or minor corrections)

Latest News

  • Call for papers - IJALS August 2015

    Manuscripts are invited for publication in IJALS - February 2016 Issue. PLEASE REGISTER TO SUBMIT YOUR MANUSCRIPT ONLINE.
  • United Life Publication Welcomes Reviewers

    We welcome Competent Academicians, Professors, Eminent scholars who are interested in peer-review to join us as reviewers. Please register your details through the reviewer form.
  • Welcome to IJLSER

    We take pride and pleasure in launching “International Journal for Life Sciences and Educational Research...
  • United Life Publication Welcomes Reviewers

    We welcome Competent Academicians, Professors, Eminent scholars who are interested in peer-review to join us as reviewers. Please register your details through the reviewer form.
  • United Life Publication Welcomes Reviewers

    We welcome Competent Academicians, Professors, Eminent scholars who are interested in peer-review to join us as reviewers. Please register your details through the reviewer form.

Announcement

  • 3rd international Plant Physiology Congress: Challenges and Strategies in Plant Biology Research

    The conference will bring together the leading scientists and scholars in the area of plant biology to discuss the practical challenges, concerns and strateg

    More..
  • International Conference on Bioinformatics, Biochemistry and Bioscience

    The 2015 International Conference on Bioinformatics, Biochemistry and Bioscience is the premier forum for the presentation of tech

    More..
  • 3rd International Confrence on Environmental Friendly Agriculture & Horticulture in Planning of a Sm

    The conference will bring together globally renowned scientists, research scholars, governmental officials and students from the universities all around the

    More..
  • Current Scenario and Future Prospects of Biotechnology in Diverse Sectors (CSFPB-2015)

    The  multidisciplinary conference also aims to shed light on the translational nature of biotechnological research, with emphasis on both the basic scie

    More..
  • Global Conference on Renewable Energy (GCRE)

    CESD-Net is a major global initiative in energy and sustainable development.The objective of network is to promote energy and s

    More..
  • International Seminar (CC 2015) on Climate Change: Impact on Developing Countries

    The Seminar aims to understand and ascertain the anthropogenically driven change in climate and to foster the exchange of adaptation and response strategies

    More..
  • International Conference on MOOCs, Innovation and Technology in Education (MITE) - 2015 IEEE

    The aim of MITE 2015 is to provide a forum for academicians and professionals from various educational fields with cross-disciplinary interests to network, s

    More..
  • 12th Knowledge Globalization Conference

    The Knowledge Globalization Conferences organized by the Knowledge Globalization Institute ai

    More..
  • The Zonal Clinical Cardiology Update CARDIOZONE -2015

    On behalf of organizing committee CARDIOZONE 2015 CALICUT, We take great pleasure in inviting you to attend the "The Zonal Clinical Cardiology Update CA

    More..
  • International Conference on Agriculture, Veterinary & Environmental Sciences 2015

    This International Conference on Agriculture , Veterinary & Environmental Sciences - 2015 (ICAVES) is Govt of Indi

    More..
  • Integrating Climate, Crop, Ecology-The Emerging Areas Of Agriculture, Horticulture, Livestock, Fishe

    The conference will bring together leading researchers, entrepreneurs and academicians in the domain of interest from around the world. Topics of interest fo

    More..
  • FLAME Case Conference

    The FLAME Centre for Case Development (FCCD) invites academicians, researchers and professionals, within and outside India, across disciplines such as manage

    More..
  • National Conference on Biofuels & Bioenergy (NCBB-2015)

    This conference intends to provide an opportunity to the experts from all over the country to showcase their innovations and findings towards the advancement

    More..
  • International Conference on Food, Ecological and Life Sciences (FELS-2015)

    The aim objective of 2015 International Conference on Food, Ecological and Life Sciences (FELS-2015) is to provide a platform f

    More..
  • International Conference on Food and agricultural Engineering (ICFAE)

    The IRES More..

  • International Conference on Advances in Applied Science, Environmental Engineering and E-Technology

    Welcome to the International Conference on Advances in Applied Science, Environmental Engineering and E-Technology . The CRCHS is a non-profit inte

    More..
  • International Conference on Biotechnology and Bioengineering

    The ICBB  2015: International Conference on Biotechnology and Bioengineering aims to bring together leading academic scientists, professors, r

    More..
  • 2nd International Conference on Advances in Environment, Agriculture & Medical Sciences (ICAEAM 15)

    2nd International Conference on Advances in Environment, Agriculture & Medical Sciences (ICAEAM'15) scheduled on June 11-12, 2015 at Antaly

    More..
  • 2nd Annual International Conference on Agriculture and Forestry 2015

    From 2014, ICOAF continues its momentum to explore and capture benefits from emerging developments in agriculture and forestry.

    More..

Alerts